Finding the Edge: The Power of the Right Claim

The right claim doesn’t just describe a product, it creates an edge. It’s what sparks interest, drives trial, and turns attention into action. But when every product makes a claim, standing out takes more than simply stating a benefit.

To truly differentiate on pack, in communications, and in consumers’ minds, brands need to find the right hook: the insight that makes people stop, think, and reappraise their choices. This isn’t just about what a product does; it’s about how that truth is expressed. The most powerful claims connect meaning and motivation, turning a functional benefit into something emotionally compelling and commercially potent.

In this article, we’ll explore a 3-step process to make a strong claim that truly works. To show how research can reveal the emotional and cognitive levers behind effective messaging, and how brands can craft claims that both resonate with consumers and deliver measurable impact in market. Whether you’re shaping innovation, refining pack design, or optimising comms, understanding the art and science of claims will give you the tools to create messaging that doesn’t just inform, it inspires action.

Strong claims: a 3-step process

Step 1. Potential claims generation

Exploratory research helps uncover what consumers truly value in a product and identifies the most compelling ways to communicate those benefits. This approach is especially crucial for new products or categories, where understanding emotional and practical drivers can shape more motivating and effective claims.

Techniques: Focus is uncovering motivating insights

  • In-depth interviews: Stakeholders, customers, or experts​

  • Focus groups: Ideate needs, emotional, and practical drivers​

  • Ethnographic: How do people use the category today?​

  • Customer journey mapping: Pain points and opportunities​

  • Social listening: Analyse organic conversations/sentiment​

Key considerations:​

  • Diversity: Capture a wide range of insights, find new perspectives, and ideas

  • Needs: Look for recurring themes, unmet needs, and emotional triggers​

  • Document: Collect video and verbatim for later trade and public comms

Step 2. Claims development

This step involves transforming qualitative insights into clear, testable claims that resonate with consumers. By using analytics to evaluate and refine these claims, or blend elements from multiple ideas, teams can identify the most compelling language to express product benefits and differentiation.

Techniques: Focus on specific motivating language

  • Synthesize: Core themes and value propositions​

  • Draft claims: Reflect benefits, differentiators, or emotional appeal​

  • Categorise claims: Functional, emotional, and social dimensions​

  • Align claims: Vs. brand positioning and strategic goals​

Key considerations:​

  • Clarity: Refine until clear, concise, and compelling​

  • Realistic and supportable: Avoid overpromising​

  • Regulatory and legal: Consider now to win later​

  • Prioritise: Based on consumer relevance and uniqueness

Step 3. Validating the claims

This final step assesses whether the claims are credible, compelling, and ready for market communication. Through testing and expert review, it ensures each claim resonates with consumers and meets the standards for packaging, advertising, and competitive response.

Techniques: Focus on the proof

  • Quantitative: Defendable proof of believability, relevance, and purchase intent​

  • Expert reviews: Scientific, legal, or technical substantiation​

Key considerations:​

  • Validation: Use statistically significant sample sizes​

  • Market standards: E.g. US requires n:300, UK only n:100​

  • War game: What is most likely competitor response? Get the facts you’ll need to respond

  • Scepticism or confusion: This holds back impact

  • Protocols: We will advise but need to ensure fairness

  • Usage: On pack, TVC, billboard? Important as some are easier to remove than others!

This 3-step framework ensures that product claims are not only inspiring but also credible, legally sound, and strategically aligned for market success.

Claims top tips

Build your claims portfolio

If you ever get challenged on your claim, you need to ensure all the evidence is documented and saved in one place to ensure it stands up in court. Therefore, we recommend creating a claims portfolio.  This can include:

  • Proposal

  • Schedule of work (SoW)

  • Informed consent form

  • Participant instructions

  • Protocol

  • Screener

  • Questionnaire

  • Report

  • Raw data

  • Data tables

  • Video footage

  • Project images

We have also put together ‘6 Steps to Set Up a Robust Claims Trail’ that you may find useful to refer to when thinking about your claims portfolio. Or watch  ‘Claims Webinar: Making Sue You WIN’ on demand: a useful resource to aid your next claims project.

Ready to build stronger claims?

Start building stronger, sharper, and more credible claims today. Our insights experts are here to partner with you, not just as consultants, but as an extension of your own team. Whether you’re launching a new product or refining your messaging, we’ll help you uncover what truly motivates your audience and validate it with confidence.

Let’s turn insight into impact.  Contact [email protected] to elevate your claims strategy.

Ready to talk?

Tell us about your goals. Whatever the stage, whatever the horizon, let’s find a way to get your business an edge.

2025-11-10T20:02:38+00:00
Go to Top